Honeypie Bakeshop is located inside our sister cafe, Palomino (2491 S Superior St.) We make all the pies, granola and treats for all of our cafes. We are a small team of hard workin’ bakers with a passion for making pie - and joy! Our treats are made in small-batches, from scratch with locally sourced dairy, eggs, fruits, and other ingredients. You can find our handmade treats at Honeypie, SmallPie, Palomino and Comet! We also have a Honeypie Bakeshop located in the Edgewater neighborhood in Chicago!
Looking for a whole pie to take home? We can make whole pies, cookies, biscuits, and more for you! Order through our online Pie Store. We do ask for 48 hours notice. If you need something sooner, give us a call - sometimes we can accommodate! We offer a wide variety of flavors for special order...the (v) means a vegan version and the (gf) means a gluten-friendly version can be made. Please email or call us if you have questions about our treats (see the bottom of this page for a bit more info on larger special orders). bakeshop@honeypiecafe.com - 414.242.6389
WE CAN DELIVER!
We partner with Forward Courier for delivery in the Milwaukee area. Their pricing begins at $25 per delivery. We will make all the arrangements for you to send a sweet treat. If you are interested in having a pie or a special order delivered in Milwaukee - shoot us an email or give us a call for more info.
IMPORTANT INFO ABOUT LARGER SPECIAL ORDERS - > Honeypie Bakeshop loves to do special orders for weddings, birthdays, and events. We are however a tiny bakeshop inside of a bustling restaurant - we are not quite a "traditional" bakery. We are a few hard workin' bakers who love to make delicious hand-made treats. So, if you are unfamiliar with who we are - there are a few things we'd like you to know because we have some limitations due to our size and location.
1 - We can assemble a tasting for you anytime! We usually need a few days heads up to do so (4-5 is good! even more is better.) Let us know what you’re interested in trying and we’ll create a box of treats for you to take home to sample at your leisure. Or we can send it to the restaurant and you can enjoy it at a table with friends and drinks. Email us at Bakeshop@honeypiecafe.com to discuss. We typically reply within 24 hours of emailing us. If you prefer to talk with a person right away, give us a call at 414.242.6389, Mon-Sat, 9am-2pm.
2 - We have a limit to how many special orders we can take at a time. So place your order as early as you can. You can choose exact flavors closer to the event date. We mostly just need to know the quantity. We require full payment about a week prior to your order being completed. We will email an invoice that will have a link for online payment.
3 - We do offer delivery within Milwaukee and the nearby suburbs via our partners at Forward Courier. Let us know where you'd like a delivery made and we can discuss pricing with you.
4 - We do not pre-cut the pies for your service. Pies should not be cut until just prior to serving so your slices will hold up!
Give us a call or email us with any questions you have. We'd love to make treats for your special day.
(414) 242.6389 | bakeshop@honeypiecafe.com